Capital Distortion
Every allocation is made again.
Every budget cycle, each ongoing initiative gets funded again. That’s an allocation decision, and it’s rarely made as one. This Note is about what that costs, and why nobody can add it up.
Early in my career I worked at Wells Fargo Nikko Investment Advisors, on the team, led by Donald Luskin, that created LifePath. Launched in 1994, it was one of the first families of target-date funds, built for 401(k) participants. The funds rebalanced continuously, becoming less volatile as participants approached their investment horizon. What drove those funds was tactical asset allocation.
A portfolio built that way never holds anything because it held it yesterday. Every position is decided again, against what the money is for and how much time is left.
An enterprise holds a portfolio too. Programs, platforms, initiatives, and commitments, each approved once, on a business case, by people who were right to approve it.
Most of that portfolio is decided once, at approval. After that it is renewed.
Renewal is not a review
Every budget cycle, each ongoing initiative is funded again. That is an allocation decision, as real as the first one, and it is rarely made as one. The question in the room is whether the program is on plan and on budget, not whether the enterprise would start it today.
Some of what gets renewed is doing exactly what it should. Some of it has failed, and failure is the easy case: it shows up, someone owns it, it gets stopped.
The hard case sits between. An initiative that neither fails nor builds. It reports activity, meets its milestones, keeps its team, and leaves the organization no more capable than the day it began. It consumes resource without compounding capability. That is zombie capital. It hasn’t failed, so nobody has to explain it. It hasn’t succeeded, so nobody has to defend it.
Why nobody can total it
Ask how much zombie capital your organization is carrying and you will get one of two answers: a shrug, or the budget line.
The budget line is real, and it’s the only part that adds up. The initiative holds more than that. Engineers maintain it who could be building something else. An executive chairs its steering group every month. Knowledge gets spent keeping an old platform alive. A partner built a roadmap around it. And if it stopped, the sponsor’s standing would take the hit.
None of that has a ledger. An enterprise spends six capital domains: financial, human, intellectual, reputational, political, and social. Only the first is totaled, so only the first appears in any review of what the portfolio costs.
This Note has no headline figure, and that is deliberate. There is no reliable number for how much capital organizations hold this way, because no instrument in the building produces one. A Note that opened by asserting a size would be making the error it describes.
Continuing is diffuse. Stopping is visible.
This is Capital Distortion. A governance system built to read financial capital clearly reads the other five domains dimly or not at all. No one decides to carry zombie capital. The governance system carries it, and no one has to decide anything.
It does so in two ways. The cost of continuing is spread across domains nobody adds up, so it never reaches the point that forces a decision. The cost of stopping is concentrated: a write-off on one line, and a sponsor who has to say out loud that the case changed. Continuing is diffuse and stopping is visible, so continuing wins by default.
So release comes late, if it comes at all. Usually under pressure, when a downturn or a new leader forces the portfolio open and the options are fewest.
Giving the decision to release capital the same standing as the decision to commit it, and reading what each commitment holds across all six domains, is the work of Capital Symmetry Governance™. That work is larger than one Note. One Note can hand you a screen.
Take the five largest initiatives your organization has funded for more than a year. Ask four questions of each.
- What can the organization do now, because of it, that it could not do when it began?
- If it were proposed today, with what you now know, would it be funded?
- Who would have to decide to stop it, and what would they have to admit?
- When was its funding last decided, rather than renewed?
No answer to the first and a no to the second: that is zombie capital. The third question tells you why it is still running. The fourth tells you how long it has run unexamined. If it has built something and the something sits in the wrong place, that is a different problem.
Then size what you found. Take each initiative you flagged and write down what it holds in each of the six domains, starting with the budget line.
Only the first row adds up. The other five you can fill only with names. That is the finding. The capital is real, and nothing your board reads can total it.
— Greg