Capital Snowmelt
The transformation closed. The loan is still open.
A transformation can close on time, on budget, and still be a loan. This Note is my attempt to name what it borrowed from, and why nobody schedules the payment.
The closing slide
Most transformations end with a slide. Milestones met. Savings booked, sometimes ahead of plan. A new operating model in place, a sponsor thanked, a team released back to its day job.
If you sit on a board, you’ve seen one, and it was probably accurate. The program did what it was chartered to do. The board was right to approve it and right to accept the close.
What the slide cannot show is how the result was paid for. This Note is about that.
The gain that does not stay
In 2018, McKinsey surveyed nearly 1,800 people about their organizations’ digital transformations. Only 16% said theirs had improved performance and also equipped the organization to sustain the change over the long term.
Three years later McKinsey asked again, about transformations of every kind. Fewer than a third of respondents reported both improving performance and sustaining it. More than half of the value lost was lost during and after implementation—a fifth of it after the work was fully done.
Both surveys are self-reported, and the second measures lost value, not total value. They point the same way. Most programs produce something real, and much of it does not stay.
The usual explanation is execution: the change was not embedded, the sponsor moved on, attention drifted. Some of that is true. It also misses where the result came from. Read the decay as an accounting question instead: If a gain fades, what was it standing on?
What the program drew on
A transformation runs on more than its budget. It runs on a team carrying the program on top of the jobs they already had. It runs on the trust that let a supplier accept new terms without a fight. It runs on the people who knew why the old process worked, and who left once the new one was live.
None of that is in the business case. All of it is spent.
Gartner’s research puts a number on one part of it. Among employees with above-average change fatigue, only 43% intend to stay. Among those with low fatigue, 74% do. The people a program leans on hardest are the ones it is most likely to lose, and what they know leaves with them.
What they know is the intellectual draw, and it is quieter. A program that redesigns a process captures the steps and loses the reasons. The reasons lived in people: the exceptions they handled without writing down, the judgment calls nobody thought to document. When those people leave, the process still runs. It just stops knowing why.
The social draw is quieter still. A supplier who absorbed new terms, a partner who waited out a delayed integration, a customer who tolerated a rough cutover: each extended credit the program did not ask for and did not record. Most of them will extend it once.
A loan with no ledger
The gain is real, and so is the loan. Only one of them is on the books.
This is Capital Snowmelt—erosion in the diffuse capital domains while financial performance holds or improves. An enterprise spends six domains: financial, human, intellectual, reputational, political, and social. Only the first keeps a ledger.
Yesterday I wrote about my father’s notebooks: rainfall, highs and lows, where the antenna pointed. My mom’s Type 1 blood glucose levels. Nothing he cared about went unrecorded. A transformation’s loan is the opposite case. Everything it drew on mattered, and none of it was written down.
So the program closes against a ledger that shows only the gain. The team is tired but present. The supplier is still a supplier. The person who knew is gone, and the process runs without them until the first exception it was never designed for. Each of those is a balance that changed, and none of them reaches a board pack in a form anyone would recognize as a liability.
The financial result is the last place the loan appears, often years after it was drawn. The decision to draw it is visible much earlier. It is made the day the plan assumes the same people can carry the program and the business at once, and nobody prices that assumption.
Repayment has to be scheduled
Every other loan an enterprise takes carries a rate, a schedule, and an owner. This one carries none, because nothing records that it was taken.
Recording it is not an HR exercise or a change-management checklist. It is a governance act: reading what each program draws from all six domains, before it starts and again after it closes. A board can start by asking for three things:
- What each program assumes it can draw from people, knowledge, and relationships before it begins;
- Who owns that draw while it runs;
- What condition those domains are in a year after the close, read with the same seriousness as the savings.
That is the work of Capital Symmetry Governance™, and it is larger than one Note.
One Note can ask two questions.
Take the last transformation your organization called a success.
- Which of the six capitals paid for it?
- What was the repayment plan?
If the second question has no answer, the program did not finish. It closed, and the balance carried forward.
Greg